Thursday, 28 July 2011
Synoptic Stemmata: Streeter vs. my own
Tuesday, 26 July 2011
PhD Position in either Patristic, Early Christian or Late Antique studies f/m
It concerns a fully-paid doctoral position at VU University Amsterdam (4 years), supervised by Prof. Paul van Geest and Prof. Hagit Amirav. In principle, there are no teaching and course work obligations involved.
Please follow the link:
http://www.vu.nl/nl/Images/1.2011.00162_tcm9-222709.pdf
Bookflyer for 'Christ's Resurrection in Early Christianity'
The bookflyer has appeared:
This is the first Patristic book to focus on the development of the belief
in the Resurrection of Christ through the first centuries A.D.
By Paul, Christ’s Resurrection is regarded as the basis of Christian
hope. In the fourth century it becomes a central Christian tenet. But
what about the discrepancy in the first three centuries? Vinzent offers
an eye-opening experience with insights into the craftsmanship of
early Christianity – the earliest existential debates about life and
death, death and life – all centred on the cross, on suffering, enduring
and sacrifice.
To order, please visit:
www.ashgate.comAll online orders receive a discount
Alternatively, contact our distributor:
Bookpoint Ltd, Ashgate Publishing Direct Sales,
130 Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon, OX14 4SB, UK
Tel: +44 (0)1235 827730 Fax: +44 (0)1235 400454
Email: ashgate@bookpoint.co.uk
August 2011
282 pages
Hardback
978-1-4094-1791-0
£60.00
Paperback
978-1-4094-1792-7
£19.99
Christ’s Resurrection in
Early Christianity
and the Making of the New Testament
Markus Vinzent
, King’s College London UK‘Professor Vinzent takes the reader on a fascinating journey through virtually every Christian text from the
first two centuries in order to demonstrate the validity of his thesis. His judgments…are based on a
thorough reading of the evidence. This book constitutes a great achievement to which I am sure I shall have
frequent recourse.’
– Gerd Lüdemann, Georg-August-University Göttingen, Germany
‘Potentially revolutionary, utterly controversial, and endlessly fascinating, this book … raises as many
questions about the contours of early Christianity and the emergence of the canon as it seeks to answer. It
will surely spark scholarly debate and discussion for years to come. No serious scholar of early Christianity
can ignore it.’
– Mark DelCogliano, University of St. Thomas, St. Paul, Minnesota , USA
‘Markus Vinzent’s new monograph tackles head-on the grossly undertreated historical problem of the dearth
of literary expositions and artistic representations of the resurrection of Jesus in pre-Nicene Christianity…
Vinzent’s study exposes how the passion of Christ, for a sustained period, dominated early Christian
soteriology in its doctrinal and liturgical manifestations. This book will significantly aid in revising historical
reconstructions of Christian identity in its formative stages in antiquity.’
– Paul M. Blowers, Emmanuel Christian Seminary, Johnson City, USA
Sample pages for published titles are available to view online at: www.ashgate.com
Contents:
the end; Paul and the Resurrection rediscovered; Celebrating life and
death; Bibliography; Index.
Introduction: a rise of the risen Christ?; The beginnings ofNow available from Ashgate Publishing…
Friday, 22 July 2011
The Gospel of the Hebrews and Marcion's Gospel
In 2006, Pier Franco Beatrice (Padua), one of our creative Patristic scholars, published a substantial article on 'The "Gospel according to the Hebrews" in the Apostolic Fathers', Novum Testamentum 48 (2006): 147-95.
Pier Franco was so kind to point me to this article. Here my preliminary responds which shows how much we still do not know, and how much we still have to research and check.
For years now, since Joseph Kürzinger's times - I contributed to his book with the edition and translation of Papias' fragments my very first scholarly publication, the bibliography raisonnee -, while I am not saying that his interpretation convinced me then or now, I have worked on Papias, the Kerygma Petrou, the Gospel of Peter (on the latter I had to do a translation and introduction for the New Schneemelcher, over 10 years ago which still has not appeared and, I fear, a contribution which will be somehow out of date when it will appear), Ignatius and Marcion. Some of Beatrice's suggestions in the above article are not far off from the way I see it:
- I can see the point of combining all the Petrine evidence and to see them derived from one document, although it is a hypothesis that hangs on a number of assumptions, probably the most difficult for me is why the Clement fragments are so coherent, but do not display a Gospel type of writing, while the Gospel of Peter does not display the Clement fragments' character of the Kerygma. But there might be a way to overcome this.
- I have neither a principle problem with the possibility that Ignatius quotes from the Gospel of the Hebrews. In both cases, there is a clear Petrine emphasis given in both backgrounds which also explains the relation between the Gospel of the Hebrews and whatever we call the Petrine text. And it is also quite clear that the text relates to the post-resurrection passage that we know off from Marcion's Gospel.
- As Beatrice rightly assume, the dating of both Ignatius and Papias is not clear (around Marcion's time, which is not fully clear either).
- I may even understand his interpretation of Papias, although we simply do not know precisely what he means, but what seems clear is that somehow the two names that he mentions became later related to what we know today as canonical gospels. But I agree, he himself could have meant the two other texts above. If so, we are left with a Hebrew Gospel and a Petrine Gospel
- I don't think that Papias knew of Luke or John; as to what Beatrice mentions in note 142, these opinions are derived from misreading the Armenian texts published by Siegert
- I am also sceptical about his interpretation of Polycarp to the Philippians. Of course, one can relate this text to the Gospel of Hebrews, but the reference to a 'man' who 'is first-born of Satan' is more clearly related to a single author (Marcion?) than to an anonymous Gospel called according to many, namely the Hebrews - obviously without a relation of this Gospel to one single author. And again, the relation that Beatrice makes between IgnPhilad. 8,2 to the Gospel of the Hebrews is less convincing ('nothing really prevents us' is less than an argument). If one admits that it is a supposition 'that the Gospel of the Hebrews' was at the centre of fierce debate in the Christian communities' - there are really little traces left of this 'fierce debate'. We do not have a single work against this Gospel (in contrast to a whole range of books against Marcion and his Gospel with Tertullian's full commentary on it), on the contrary, we have here and there, as Beatrice shows, references to it and, if we follow his argument, even appreciations of it as in Papias, Ignatius and others (altough I would be more cautious and not call the series of assumptions and arguments 'an absolutely clear way', p. 186, but this might be a matter of style). When one draws from these references that this Gospel 'was a very old and authoritative gospel around the years 110-140CE' - I doubt that 'very old' can mean much, as Papias/John does not make the link with the Apostles, nor does anybody else (contrary to the Gospel of Peter that is being linked with the Apostle). So how old was the Gospel of the Hebrews? Marcion claims that his Gospel is that of which Paul spoke. Does he mean that it was written by Paul - of course not, but that, as Marcion says according to Tertullian, that it enlightens what Paul meant to say. I am so sceptical about our past 200 years scholarship that has traced all sorts of things (see for example the Apostles' Creed) to the first century. If this were correct, why have only authors of around 110-140 (and I rather think towards to end of this window) started quoting not only this Gospel of the Hebrews, but Gospels at all.
- I agree with Beatrice's scepticism about Irenaeus (probably Theophilus?) assertion that Marcion circumcized a Gospel, why is Justin not telling us about this (or anybody else prior to Irenaeus)? I think we first needed the other Gospels and the acceptance of those to benchmark what Marcion had in hands.
- If I understood Beatrice correctly than we are in the same boat here with one difference that he believes that Marcion used an earlier Gospel (of course which is contradicted by a strong opinion of Marcion himself who does claim that he did not use Luke and is silent about the use of any other sources except Paul), while I am still thinking about potential sources of him. Having worked on this question for a few years now, I strongly believe that Marcion's Gospel was his own creation and that Luke (together with all the other later canonical gospels) are re-writings of it.
Having read his article, I will certainly look more closely about the potential relation between the Gospel of the Hebrews and Marcion's Gospel. From what I have read in the past, I had the impression that the Gospel of the Hebrews was also a reaction to that of Marcion, but that opinion might be revised in the light of what Beatrice says and what I need to check again. Marcion must have had sources beyond Paul, but were these in written form? The Gospel of the Hebrews? Or could the Gospel of the Hebrews be what Marcion criticized to have been the publication of his own Gospel by others (even prior to his own publication of it with the Antitheses) in which the link had been made with the Law and the Prophets, a description which could well fit the title of the Gospel of the Hebrews which is, of course, precisely the opposite of what Marcion suggested, namely a Pauline Gospel that shows that the Hebrews did not understand a word and that therefore, the Gentiles were the only hope for the new belief.
Friday, 1 July 2011
Marcion's Healing of the Leper
Dear Stephan,
your comments are anything but time consuming, on the contrary - it needs queer thinking in a field which is so cluttered with apology and for all of us so remote through sheer hundreds of years of apologetic distortion. Whether to trust a source, never any trust, but detective eyes. Alliance to institutions? None, sheer looking for understanding. Which is difficult enough. Now what you write about the Creator and the Cross is highly interesting, to deep for me to come up with a short answer. I don't have one, yet. From Marcion's Gospel which I am about to restore at best as I can and the sources allow, I am impressed, how intelligent and lucid it is, perhaps the most thought through of all, except John, but certainly better thought through than Mark or even Matthew, and Luke seems often simply helpless how to deal with it. Extraordinary to see that nobody had attempted a comparative reading of Marcion's Gospel with the others. Let me come back to the destruction of the temple. I have not come to the temple, yet, but I was struck by the pericope on which I am working now (known as the Healing of the Leper, but characterized by Marcion as the story of the companion in misery and hatred), where Marcion says that the Lord asked the healed to present himself to the priest and bring the offering for his cleansing, 'as Moses commanded, that it may be for a testimony to them'. Isn't that astonishing? Even Tertullian is struck. But he is even more struck (and argues, of course, against it) that Marcion's reason for stating this is that he contrasts Christ's God with that of Elisha who's servant is less than the master himself. Different with Christ's God - Christ has the same standing as God, there is no hierarchy between him and God. This Christ is of the same gentleness and clemency as God himself. That is why he even accepts that the one who is healed can carry on with his customary duty, note: his Jewish duty, commanded by Mose! What I like with your speculative thinking (and what could we achieve without in these difficult fields), is its creativity, based on and corrected by evidence. Let us see what the further reading of Marcion's Gospel will reveal. Already now, I have learned so much, and I am sure, this text will tell us more about him.
your comments are anything but time consuming, on the contrary - it needs queer thinking in a field which is so cluttered with apology and for all of us so remote through sheer hundreds of years of apologetic distortion. Whether to trust a source, never any trust, but detective eyes. Alliance to institutions? None, sheer looking for understanding. Which is difficult enough. Now what you write about the Creator and the Cross is highly interesting, to deep for me to come up with a short answer. I don't have one, yet. From Marcion's Gospel which I am about to restore at best as I can and the sources allow, I am impressed, how intelligent and lucid it is, perhaps the most thought through of all, except John, but certainly better thought through than Mark or even Matthew, and Luke seems often simply helpless how to deal with it. Extraordinary to see that nobody had attempted a comparative reading of Marcion's Gospel with the others. Let me come back to the destruction of the temple. I have not come to the temple, yet, but I was struck by the pericope on which I am working now (known as the Healing of the Leper, but characterized by Marcion as the story of the companion in misery and hatred), where Marcion says that the Lord asked the healed to present himself to the priest and bring the offering for his cleansing, 'as Moses commanded, that it may be for a testimony to them'. Isn't that astonishing? Even Tertullian is struck. But he is even more struck (and argues, of course, against it) that Marcion's reason for stating this is that he contrasts Christ's God with that of Elisha who's servant is less than the master himself. Different with Christ's God - Christ has the same standing as God, there is no hierarchy between him and God. This Christ is of the same gentleness and clemency as God himself. That is why he even accepts that the one who is healed can carry on with his customary duty, note: his Jewish duty, commanded by Mose! What I like with your speculative thinking (and what could we achieve without in these difficult fields), is its creativity, based on and corrected by evidence. Let us see what the further reading of Marcion's Gospel will reveal. Already now, I have learned so much, and I am sure, this text will tell us more about him.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

